SPN S408

[layne67]

Did Sam make a wish? He was seen holding that coin in the second last scene. And I was under the impression that Dean really did not remember his time in hell. He has those nightmares and flashes of memories but I thought that's just about it. But now he's saying that he remembers it all but he's not going to tell Sam anything.

Sounds a lot like a wish gone wrong, IMO. Sam wished for Dean to remember but he didn't specifically said for Dean to tell him about it. So Dean remembers, and suffers. Alone.

What do you think? No spoilers please!

And oh. Another fanfic got Kripke'd :D

Wish by baylorsr.

When the shower scene first appeared, I was thinking "OMG Castiel really is going to make his appearance while Dean's in the shower!"

ETA : And is there anyone else who thought that the Trickster might be involved at first?

Comments

[angels3.livejournal.com]

I know but did you really think a thing like minor surgery would keep me away from our boys?

My husband thought it was all kinds of amusing watching me try to not laugh the bastard.

I loved Sam's wish personally, I think it scared the shit out of Dean. I think the theory of Dean having seen Sam evil in hell may have some merit to it but I don't think it's all he saw, not by a long shot.

[layne67.livejournal.com]

Oh no, there's a theory going on that Dean had seen evil!Sam in hell? :((

[angels3.livejournal.com]

Yea, I can't remember whose journal it was said that they thought the reason Dean didn't want to tell Sam about his time in hell was because he had been tortured by Sam. You know Sam going evil and the like which I guess would play to Uriel's little speech but.....

I'm more inclined to believe that Dean doesn't want to tell Sam because why would you tell someone you love something like that. I mean really! You wouldn't ever want them to have that knowledge. On top of that the boy already feels guilty for you dying and not getting you out so what, you're going to tell him how bad hell was. I don't think so.

Also I think Dean may have learned some things down there that may have him confused as well as worried that he's not ready to share on top of that he's done a lot of sharing and Sam's done a shit load of lying or avoiding so he may feel like it's time for Sam to do some sharing before he does.

[layne67.livejournal.com]

Oh no, I refuse to believe that! Mostly because Dean would have readily agreed with Castiel that Sam should be stopped, though stop doesn't necessarily mean kill, in Dean's books at least.

[angels3.livejournal.com]

Yea, I can't go with that theory either although I can see the demon's using Sam's face in order to torture Dean. You know using his fears against him. It's not really Sam but since Dean's terrified he can't keep Sam safe then the demon's used it as one more means to torment him while he was there.